As numerous health systems end supportive medical treatments during a crackdown from the current federal leadership, scientists and advocates warn that the understanding of sex and gender is being misrepresented – with major repercussions for healthcare for all Americans.
Expert Knowledge Being Challenged
Federal officials “don’t actually understand the science at all,” noted one expert, founder of Beyond X&Y and a doctoral degree holder in genetic science. The expert added that using misinformation to limit healthcare access is a dangerous precedent for all patients.
“This pushback are essentially coming from a wider effort to dismantle science and expertise and facts,” they said.
Jess McLaughlin, an researcher of biological sciences at the University of Alaska Anchorage, commented: “These oversimplified understandings of the science of biological sex are being used to justify transgender legislation and federal policy.”
McLaughlin explained: “The research is being distorted in such a way to cause harm.”
Policy Changes Restrict Treatment
The US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is implementing a new rule that would prohibit Medicaid and Medicare payments for gender-affirming care to patients under 18, including drugs like puberty blockers and estrogen or testosterone. The public comment period for this policy recently concluded. The HHS would also bar government plans from paying for this care.
Consequently, major clinics – including facilities in New York, Washington, and Utah – say they have ended their youth treatment programs, drastically reducing the ability of transgender youth to appropriate care across the country.
Care for Adults Also Targeted
Care for adults has also come under fire. The federal leadership recently stated it would stop offering gender-affirming healthcare to trans people in correctional facilities. Jailed trans people will not have access to personal items that align with their gender; anyone on hormones will be forced to taper off. The new policy claims gender identity is “separate from biological reality” and “offers no meaningful basis for recognition”.
Wider Consequences for Medicine
Scientists have also said that restricting treatment based on distorted science could set a path for limiting other types of treatment, like abortion and vaccines.
“This isn't only about attacking trans people, it’s undermining women’s rights, bodily autonomy around pregnancy termination, disabled people, individuals on the spectrum,” McCreight said. “This is part of a bigger push to try to force compliance to what’s seen as an ideal, but that ideal really comes from white Christian nationalism, not evidence-based fact.”
The HHS directive referred to gender-affirming care as “sex-rejecting procedures”, a phrase that appears to have started with a faith-based organization. This rhetoric implies “a very strict set of characteristics that are permanent,” McLaughlin said, “but that is incorrect.”
Complicated Biology of Biological Sex
Global organizations warn against conflating gender with biology, which is usually defined by “physical and physiological features” like genetic markers, gene expression, hormones, and anatomy.
The administration has had multiple difficulties in its effort to establish a biological definition to restrict care.
An presidential directive aimed at “gender ideology extremism” and claimed that biological sex is “unchangeable”, with men and women determined by sperm and egg present “from fertilization”.
Those claims are flawed in several ways. When eggs are first fertilized by sperm, they are single-celled – meaning they do not possess separate reproductive cells. The cells that later become eggs begin to form months later in pregnancy. Sperm cells only develop during puberty.
The executive order did not mention intersex people, who have differences in chromosomes and physiology.
What is 'Sex'?
“A fundamental problem is: what on earth are we even talking about with ‘biological sex’? Is it about genetics? Because that doesn’t often match,” McLaughlin said. “Most people actually have no idea what their XX or XY status are.”
While most people with XX chromosomes are women and XY chromosomes are men, there are also variations like men with XX chromosomes, women with XY chromosomes, and other patterns like XXY. “Science never really operates in clear-cut pairs,” McCreight said. “People have way more genetic variation than you would expect.”
Genes give the body directions for development, McLaughlin said, adding: “Just like handing actors a script is the beginning, what you end up with might be very different... because there are many additional processes that regulate and interpret that DNA code.”
Real-World Impact and False Claims
During the HHS announcement, a top administrator spoke about trans youth getting costly procedures. However, research could not find a single example of a patient under eighteen receiving that operation. It was also found that the overwhelming number of breast surgeries happen among cisgender teens. For the trans teens who require operations, it is shown to be life-saving. Removing this care “will result in trans kids... at the most severe, possibly death,” McCreight said.
Healthcare providers may also believe misinformation about sex and gender, creating additional hurdles for trans health. “You can get care that is not as effective or even harmful,” the professor said.
Trans people have long faced challenges accessing appropriate healthcare. “You hear about medical bias, where you go in for something clear like a fracture, and people will quickly suggest, ‘Well, maybe it’s because you’re trans,’” McLaughlin said.
Broad Societal Impact
Inaccurate beliefs about biology impact all people, not just the transgender community. Cisgender men in the Veterans Affairs system have had trouble getting treatment for breast cancer because of the new HHS rules.
The administration is also considering further limits on abortion medications. “Even cis people should be afraid – what are the implications for their medical treatment when you have politicians who misunderstand research that are making rules about these sorts of things?” an expert said.
“They are dismantling scientific research as a whole,” they added. “It’s all about discrediting knowledge. Because if you can’t get reliable facts, they can basically put any narrative they want out there.”